Small business 6 min read

Checkatrade vs Your Own Website: Do Tradesmen Still Need One?

Directories such as Checkatrade bring real work, but a profile is not a website. Here is what each one does for a trade business, and how to use both.

A PrimeStart guide for small businesses and trades

A smiling painter and decorator in white overalls standing by his open van with a paint tin

Ask ten electricians, plumbers or builders whether they need a website and a few will say the same thing: “I’m on Checkatrade, that’s my website.” It is an understandable view. Directories can bring in real work, and they handle reviews and listings for you. But a directory profile and a website do different jobs, and knowing the difference is what stops you paying for one when you needed the other.

What trade directories do well

Directories have earned their place. For many trades they are a genuine source of jobs.

  • They are already being searched. Customers go to a directory looking for someone, so you are in front of people with a job in mind.
  • They collect reviews. A directory gives customers an easy, familiar way to leave feedback, and gives new customers a reason to trust it.
  • Some vet their members. Checks on identity, insurance or qualifications reassure customers who have never heard of you.
  • They are quick to start. A profile can be live long before a website would be.

Where a directory falls short

You are listed next to your competitors

On a directory, the customer who found you is one tap away from the next business in the list. Some will compare three or four of you on price before they ring anyone. That is the nature of a marketplace, and it is fine, but it means the directory is introducing you to a shopper, not handing you a customer.

You pay to stay visible

Directories make money from the trades listed on them. Some charge a yearly membership, others charge each time you are shortlisted or buy a lead, and some combine the two. Check the current terms of any directory you use and add up what it costs you over a year, because that figure is the one to compare with anything else you might spend on getting work.

The profile is not yours

Your reviews, your photos and your profile live on someone else’s platform, under their rules. If you stop paying, change your plan or fall out of their criteria, your listing can disappear, and the reviews you worked for may not come with you. A website on your own domain does not depend on anyone’s membership.

It does not answer every question

A directory profile follows the directory’s template. There is only so much room for the areas you cover, the jobs you prefer, how you quote or the photos that show your standard. Those are exactly the details that decide whether a customer rings you or the next name in the list.

What your own website does that a directory cannot

  • It shows up when people search your name. Customers who hear about you, see your van or get a recommendation will often search for you before calling. Your own site, on your own domain, is the result you want them to find.
  • It says where you work, properly. A website can name every town and borough you cover and explain how far you travel for bigger jobs. Our guide to listing your areas goes through how to write it.
  • It shows your work, your way. Your best photos, your services in the words customers use, your accreditations shown accurately, and how you price.
  • No competitors on the page. When someone lands on your site, the only number on it is yours.
  • It works with Google. Your website is the address you link from your Google Business Profile, and it is what helps Google understand what you do and where.
  • It is yours. The domain, the content and the site stay with your business. Here is what to check to make sure that is true of yours.
A smiling tradesman in work overalls taking a phone call outside
When a customer finds your own website, the only number on the page is yours.

How to make your directory and your website work together

  1. Link from your profile to your website, wherever the directory allows it, so customers who want more can see more.
  2. Show your directory rating on your website, using the badge or widget the directory provides, if its terms allow it. Never copy reviews across as if they were your own testimonials.
  3. Keep your details identical. The same business name, phone number and address on your website, your directory profiles and your Google Business Profile. Mismatches confuse customers and search engines alike.
  4. Ask happy customers for a Google review too. Google reviews sit on your Google Business Profile, which you control, and appear in local search.
  5. Put your website on your van, cards and quotes. It is the one address that will not change if you switch directories.

A quick check you can do today

  • Search your business name on your phone. What comes up first: your site, your directory profile, or a competitor?
  • Add up what your directories cost you over the last twelve months.
  • If your directory listing disappeared tomorrow, where would a customer find your reviews and photos?
  • Does every listing show the same phone number?
  • Can a customer see the towns you cover in one place?

If any of those answers worries you, a simple website of your own is worth a serious look. You can see what one could look like for your trade on our web design for tradesmen page, with pages for trades such as electricians, plumbers and builders.

Questions people ask

Is Checkatrade enough on its own?

It can keep work coming in, but it leaves you dependent on one platform you do not control, and it does not give you a place of your own for the customers who search your name. Most trades are safer with both.

Should I leave the directories once I have a website?

Not necessarily. If a directory brings you work that pays for its fees, keep it. Your website does not replace it; it makes the work you already win less dependent on it.

Can I put my Checkatrade reviews on my website?

Many directories offer an official badge or widget for exactly this. Use that, within the directory’s terms, rather than copying reviews across by hand. Only show reviews from real customers.

How many pages does a trade website need?

Usually five or fewer: home, services, areas, about with your accreditations, and contact. Some trades manage well with a single, well-organised page.

Will a website get me work without SEO?

It will help you win the customers who already find you or hear about you. Reaching people who have never heard of you through Google takes ongoing local SEO work on top of a good site.

Directories rent you a place in front of customers. Your website is the place you own. The trades with the steadiest flow of work tend to use both, with every listing pointing back to a site that answers a customer’s questions quickly and on a phone. If you would like to see what yours could look like first, ask for a free homepage design.

Rather we did it for you?

We design it, write it, host it and look after it, and you see your design before it goes live.

Money back until you approve your design. Nothing goes live until you approve it.

  • Designed for your business

    Bespoke, not a template.

  • Looked after for you

    Domain, hosting, security, backups and updates.

  • You see it first

    Your design is shown before it goes live.

  • Money back until you approve

    If you do not approve your design.